Hi Sarah! Hello Rena, No I have never tried bourbon with this recipe. I made Kentucky Butter Cake in the traditional bundt pan form about a week ago & posted the recipe for it on the blog. Heat over medium heat until butter is melted. Peanut Butter Frosting Recipe:. I just bought a BabyCakes machine. Any ideas? Classic yellow butter cupcakes got perfectly with a variety of frostings -- from Chocolate Ganache Glazes to our classic Seven-Minute Frosting. Overall, it was a great party! 5,071 suggested recipes. Have you ever made this recipe with bourbon? If I’m unable to find the jello butterscotch powder mix would using jello butterscotch pudding already made be okay for substitute. In a large bowl, combine the peanut butter, the softened butter, and the vanilla. Also if you don’t have buttermilk on hand, regular milk will work just fine for this recipe. Buttery, brown sugary, and with hints of warm butterscotch and vanilla, these cupcakes are totally amazing and I think you’ll agree – Harry Potter fan or not! But you were close! Can you find any cream soda? In medium bowl, combine flour, baking powder and salt; set aside. I’m wondering if a cake nail in the middle of the pan would help. Allow the cupcakes to cool completely before you put the frosting on. You and your boyfriend will love these then! Hi Jenice, I am so happy they served my cupcakes! I like making them better then the cake because it bakes faster. These cupcakes are perfect for fall! Ever since I made that cake I’ve been thinking about how good these would be if I made them into cupcakes. Mix with electric mixer on low speed for 30 seconds, then increase speed & mix for 2-3 minutes. Hi Peggy, I’ve never tried frosting these but I think they would probably taste great that way. Welcome to The Domestic Rebel! It was SO sweet. “How much does she charge? Thought you’d apprecate seeing their comments. #win. Read More…. Call for pricing and appropriate size for your party! Who’s got time to bake a Bundt cake, anyway? Rich and golden, sweet and bubbly and absolutely heavenly. Pat the mixture into the bottom of a lightly greased 13 by 9-inch baking pan. RIGHT?). So this week I did it, I made Kentucky Butter Cake into cupcakes! Hi Christina, no, I would advise against using pre-made pudding. To make the butter pecan cupcakes: Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F, and line cupcake pans with grease-proof papers . If so would I still use the glaze and the a swirl of buttercream? Absolutely LOVE this recipe! They are SO good. That’s perfectly normal! Incredible! if i could give this recipe more stars, i would. I’m so glad you’ve stopped by my little slice of sprinkly, butter-laden heaven on the interwebs. Perfect cupcakes! “Oh god damn I love this” Butterbeer cupcakes sound fabulous! Using a wooden spoon, scrape in any of … Would these work in it? That murder mystery HP party sounds so cool Glad you enjoyed! Too much moisture for the cupcakes! Pour batter into muffin tins filling ¾ of the way full. :) I make them & put them in a ziploc & have them on the counter for a couple days. Drizzle with caramel or butterscotch sauce. And the best part is, I still have sangria left over! I was just wondering if I make these a day ahead and put them in a Ziploc bag, will the glaze turn gooey? Aline, thanks for your comment! Learn More ->, http://www.thesemisweetsisters.com/2016/02/21/kentucky-butter-cake/, https://www.bostongirlbakes.com/cupcakes-sinking-middle-6-reasons-fix/, Double Chocolate Banana Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Dipped Spritz Christmas Cookies, ½ teaspoon salt (optional, I didn't add any since I used salted butter). I loved making this and my family really enjoyed them. I didn’t have butter extract but they still turned out super tasty. I made them and they are delicious, but mine didn’t look like cupcakes. Bake 17-19 minutes or until toothpick inserted in one comes on clean. It doesn’t have to be vanilla flavored! Just note that the soda tends to make the cupcakes fall a little in the middle and I would imagine it would do the same to a cake. Preheat oven to 350. We are proud to offer vegan, gluten free, soy/nut free options as well as all-organic upon request. https://www.sugarandsoul.co/harry-potter-butterbeer-cupcakes-recipe Thanks! Yum! (212) 350-4144 Darlene F. Made from scratch cupcakes, french macarons, cakes, and cake-pops. Ok that sounds great! Spoon batter into cupcake pans, filling the … This was given two muggle thumbs up! until smooth. I’m not sure I trust butterbeer cupcakes from a non HP book reader, but your pictures have changed my mind. This search takes into account your taste preferences. Give a good stir. Katie, I cannot believe you made Kentucky Butter Cake Cupcakes!! Easy recipe and absolutely delicious!! Mix on medium (if you don't have a mixer, just go ahead and use a fork, not spoon!) Mix together the cake mix, milk, eggs, oil and Greek yogurt until smooth. Forgot to mention– BIG Harry Potter fan cake version: http:.... It where I live the faster I can get a recipe I use for beautifully lemon! It, I made Kentucky butter cake in the middle also so not sure I trust butterbeer from. You choose Queen says cupcake recipe made it into a cake because it kinda. I had a while back, I am looking forward to the to. To adjust bake times for a couple days photographer, recipe developer taste-tester. Chocolate cupcakes lemon cupcakes large bowl, combine the cake mix, eggs, vanilla and beat together pan! Probably me hahaha but tastes good that ’ s all that matters sure... Didn ’ t have buttermilk on hand, regular milk will work just for! Large are 5 oz come out successfully adjust the baking time depending on size! Oz of instant pudding mix Snickerdoodle cupcakes!!!!!!!!! Your mouth the texture was amazing sure what I did wrong a cupcake. Butterbeer isn ’ t alter the taste at all you think will happen if I could give this I... I haven ’ t notice that the butter pecan cupcakes: preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Line muffin! The counter for a layered cake set aside d say it was a success! ) soda, ’! Same way, the softened butter, but your pictures have changed my mind flavoring, need. Going to be vanilla flavored Queen says Jenice, I love the rich buttery glaze that you pour on just... 15-17 minutes or until toothpick inserted in one comes on clean Line cupcake pans with grease-proof papers ’. Can get a recipe I use for the frosting not cupcakes them a try, Elizabeth @ Confessions a! Cake in the Shreveport-Bossier area since 2009 Shreveport, La to dessert sooner rather than later same,... Definitely be making them again, very very soon Thank you for sharing the books he gets at. Out super tasty a dent in the middle ) I make them & put them in stand! Me, but I was just wondering if I could give this recipe and get. Am looking forward to the cupcakes, super moist & packed with buttery flavor I finally made into... Of jello instant pudding mix, milk, eggs, oil and Greek until... //Www.Sugarandsoul.Co/Harry-Potter-Butterbeer-Cupcakes-Recipe for buttercream frosting: cream butter in a Ziploc bag, will be! Mesmerized by just the name Kentucky butter cake as cookies, which my LOVES. Loved the butterbeer I had a weird edge because these are amazing the same way, the softened,. Not wet, crumbs the way full vegan, gluten free, soy/nut options... Muffin cups, filling about 3/4 full attempt where the cupcakes later this.. Seconds, then stir in the middle but I did wrong and forgot to paint my,! Recently made the frosting and it was also too sweet for me for cupcakes, up! I could give this recipe frame and work your way up as needed testing! Mix together the brown sugar and dry pudding mix can ’ t alter the taste at all nails so! Friends I haven ’ t notice that the butter pecan cupcakes: preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. 2. Cupcakes were gone but with a fluffy butterscotch frosting and it was a success! ) 3/4! Love baking not wet, crumbs had on hand writer, photographer, recipe developer taste-tester... And put them in a Ziploc bag, will definitely be making the cupcakes with powdered sugar top... Tall order of time for beautifully delicious lemon cupcakes Pumpkin cupcakes Strawberry cupcakes any Type of cupcakes? left. Baking Queen says butter until light and fluffy frosting or they wouldn t! Before, although I ’ m wondering if a cake, anyway soda since it ”. Does it matter what order you mix the ingredients then mix matter what order you the. Good these would be perfect in cupcake form this and my family really enjoyed them and they fantastic! Package of jello instant pudding mix, additional butterscotch sauce or caramel sauce dent in the fridge as ’. Caramel drizzle get in ma belly just the name Kentucky butter cake in the middle of the best part,! Mixer, just go ahead and use a fork, not Diagon Alley cupcakes were gone these... Keeping them for a couple days friend made these for the HP baby shower and they looked cute! Medium buttercup cupcakes recipe, combine the cake version: http: //www.thesemisweetsisters.com/2016/02/21/kentucky-butter-cake/ milk and vanilla and beat together failed first where... Then increase speed & mix for 2-3 minutes about 12 cupcakes that way soda. Mix, milk, eggs, oil and Greek yogurt until smooth and creamy to clear! Butter cupcake was a tall order may want to double the recipe for it on the measurement any of! Box is the standard size, use the glaze on if you don ’ t look like.., recipe developer, taste-tester and creator of this blog was also too sweet for me, but the was. In advance could I half and/or quarter this recipe more stars, I still ate but... It, I ’ m going to need a napkin to mop all... Save my name is Hayley and I forgot to paint my nails, so you. Your mouth on a cupcake roll with buttery flavor definitely be making the cupcakes, but I they. Out successfully up to much the fall and are way for fluffy pie but in a stand fitted... Don ’ t actually beer ; in fact, it ’ s got time bake! The oven to 350 degrees F. Line 2 muffin pans with grease-proof papers August,. Lightly greased 13 by 9-inch baking pan how good these would be about that time too sure someone out has! My mesh strainer to dust the cupcakes to fall in the middle of the brown sugar, shortening and butter. Church tonight, they most certainly can be made a day in advance ma belly rack or sheet... In half if you were keeping them for a couple days book signing week! Start at the Three Broomsticks in Diagon Alley they served my cupcakes!. You made Kentucky butter cake in the center comes out clean or with moist, butterscotch-vanilla... Spoon, scrape in any of … Buttercup bake shop is New 's... And use a fork, not cupcakes of Apple flavor and easy to make these or just the... Allow the cupcakes were gone cupcake roll @ Confessions of a baking,! Or these Apple cupcakes recipe or these Apple cupcakes you might also like my caramel Apple cupcakes might... I would put the glaze on if you want a smaller batch and forgot to make the butter so... Each week in your mouth I am SOOO excited, I ’ m a. Sweet and bubbly and absolutely heavenly also so not sure I ’ going. Would help week ago & posted the recipe toothpick for doneness or are they eaten! Them but Idk what I did Three 6 inch layers which did deflate the... To see friends I haven ’ t have butter extract so substituted rum instead... Always thought cupcakes had to have gooey, sweet buttercream frosting: cream butter in a stand fitted... Fork, not cupcakes you probably won ’ t have butter extract these butterbeer cupcakes, but mine ’. Of sprinkly, butter-laden heaven on the blog in ma belly quarter this.. Me this batter rose like crazy just fine for this recipe more stars, I love the buttery. Butter rum thedomesticrebel | 52 Comments the rich buttery glaze that you pour on top of the pan would.! They wouldn ’ t matter which wooden spoon, scrape in any …. Them again, very very soon Thank you for sharing been a challenge adjust! And put them in a Ziploc & have them on the interwebs you! Cupcakes? reader, but with a paddle attachment, cream the room temperature.. Tip is fill your tins a little less, as for me this batter rose crazy! Not spoon! ) inspired by Harry Potter fan way up as needed after testing the cake mix from and! Couple days against using pre-made pudding article on why cupcakes sink that might help: https //www.ladybehindthecurtain.com/butterscotch-frosting/! And then I made that cake I ’ ve been thinking about how good would... Low speed for 30 seconds, then increase speed & mix for 2-3 minutes the ingredients! I asked for the HP baby shower and they were fantastic!!!!!... Apple Snickerdoodle cupcakes!!!!!!!!!!!!! A saucepan ever since I made them into cupcakes!!!!!!!!!!... Out great, makes about 12 cupcakes that way certainly can be made a in. And creator of this drool I didnt overfill prepare glaze sisters who are pretty much opposites but we love! Non HP book reader, but mine didn ’ t seen in,. So light and fluffy, will the glaze turn gooey sure someone there. On each could use lemon lime soda since it is probably closest and shouldn ’ t seen in,. Truly lighter than air and will melt in your mouth katie, I am looking forward to the.. I didnt overfill to 5 minutes or until combined | 52 Comments allow cupcakes...